best crime junkie podcasts

Introduction to Crime Junkie Podcasts

True crime podcasts have taken the world by storm, captivating audiences with their chilling tales of mystery, intrigue, and the darkest corners of the human psyche. If you’re a fan of this genre, chances are you’ve heard of Crime Junkie, one of the most popular true crime podcasts in the podcasting landscape.

Crime Junkie, hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, has gained a massive following for its engaging storytelling, meticulous research, and the hosts’ undeniable chemistry. With each episode, they delve into fascinating crime stories, exploring the details, motives, and aftermaths of various criminal cases.

In this comprehensive blog post, we will embark on a deep dive into the world of Crime Junkie podcasts, exploring the best episodes, analyzing the factors that make a true crime podcast stand out, and introducing other rising stars in the genre. Whether you’re a seasoned true crime enthusiast or just dipping your toes into this captivating realm, this guide will serve as your ultimate resource for finding the best Crime Junkie podcasts to satisfy your crime cravings.

But what exactly sets Crime Junkie apart from the multitude of true crime podcasts out there? Ashley and Brit bring a unique style to the genre, infusing their storytelling with a genuine passion for justice and a dedication to factual accuracy. Their episodes are meticulously researched, leaving no stone unturned in their quest to present the most accurate and compelling narratives. This dedication to detail is what truly sets Crime Junkie apart, ensuring that listeners are not only entertained but also informed.

Moreover, the hosts’ chemistry is undeniable. Ashley and Brit’s friendship and shared love for true crime shine through in every episode. Their banter, empathy, and genuine reactions make you feel like you’re sitting in a room with friends, discussing the most captivating crime stories of our time. It is this relatability and authenticity that have garnered Crime Junkie a dedicated and passionate fan base.

Now, let’s dive into the criteria we will use to select the best Crime Junkie podcasts. From engaging storytelling to production quality, we will explore the key factors that make a true crime podcast a must-listen for any crime junkie. So, buckle up and get ready to explore the fascinating world of Crime Junkie podcasts!

Criteria for Selecting the Best Crime Junkie Podcasts

As a true crime enthusiast, you may find yourself overwhelmed by the sheer number of crime podcasts available. With new shows popping up left and right, how do you know which ones are worth your time? When it comes to selecting the best Crime Junkie podcasts, there are several key criteria to consider. Let’s take a closer look at each of them:

Engaging Storytelling

One of the most crucial aspects of any true crime podcast is its ability to captivate the listener with compelling storytelling. The best Crime Junkie podcasts excel in this area, taking you on a gripping journey through the details of each crime. From the initial setup to the final resolution, the hosts should be skilled at building suspense, maintaining intrigue, and keeping you hooked from start to finish. A great true crime podcast will make you feel like you’re right there, immersed in the story, eagerly awaiting the next revelation.

Thorough Research and Factual Accuracy

When it comes to true crime, accuracy is paramount. The best Crime Junkie podcasts prioritize thorough research, ensuring that the information presented is reliable and verified. From examining court records and police reports to conducting interviews and consulting experts, the hosts should leave no stone unturned in their quest for the truth. Factual accuracy not only enhances the credibility of the podcast but also provides listeners with a deeper understanding of the cases discussed.

Variety of Crime Genres Covered

True crime is a vast genre, encompassing a wide range of criminal activities and case types. The best Crime Junkie podcasts offer a diverse selection of crime genres, catering to different interests and preferences. Whether you’re fascinated by serial killers, unsolved mysteries, white-collar crime, or historical cases, a great true crime podcast should have something for everyone. The ability to explore a variety of crime genres ensures that the podcast remains fresh, intriguing, and appeals to a broader audience.

Production Quality and Sound Design

While content is king, production quality plays a significant role in enhancing the overall listening experience. The best Crime Junkie podcasts invest in high-quality production, ensuring clear audio, seamless editing, and immersive sound design. Smooth transitions, atmospheric music, and well-balanced sound effects can greatly enhance the storytelling, creating a more engaging and immersive experience for the listener. A podcast that prioritizes production quality demonstrates a commitment to delivering a polished and professional product.

Hosts’ Chemistry and Presentation Style

The hosts of a true crime podcast play a vital role in creating a connection with the audience. The best Crime Junkie podcasts feature hosts who possess excellent chemistry, complementing each other’s strengths and engaging in meaningful discussions. Their presentation style should be relatable, conversational, and authentic, making you feel like you’re part of the conversation. A great hosting dynamic can elevate the listening experience, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the podcast.

Listener Reviews and Ratings

Lastly, but certainly not least, taking into account listener reviews and ratings can provide valuable insights into the quality and popularity of a Crime Junkie podcast. Reading reviews and checking ratings on podcast platforms and social media communities can help you gauge the overall reception of the show. Positive feedback, high ratings, and a dedicated fan base are indicators that a podcast is doing something right and may be worth exploring further.

By considering these criteria, you’ll be well-equipped to identify the best Crime Junkie podcasts that align with your preferences and provide an exceptional listening experience. Now, let’s delve into the top Crime Junkie podcasts for true crime enthusiasts!

Top Crime Junkie Podcasts for True Crime Enthusiasts

If you’re a true crime enthusiast looking for the best Crime Junkie podcasts to satisfy your crime cravings, you’re in luck! Crime Junkie, the original podcast hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat, has a vast collection of episodes that will keep you on the edge of your seat. Let’s explore some of the top Crime Junkie podcasts that have captivated audiences and garnered rave reviews.

Crime Junkie – The Original

Crime Junkie, the podcast that started it all, has become a true crime phenomenon. Each episode follows a well-structured format, with Ashley and Brit diving deep into a different crime story. What sets Crime Junkie apart is its ability to maintain a perfect balance between presenting the facts and crafting a gripping narrative. The hosts’ storytelling skills shine through as they take you on a journey through each case, unraveling the details and exploring the motives behind the crimes. From notorious serial killers to shocking disappearances, Crime Junkie covers a wide range of cases, ensuring there’s something for every true crime enthusiast.

Some notable episodes from Crime Junkie include “The Murder of Laci Peterson,” which examines the high-profile case of a pregnant woman’s disappearance and murder, and “Missing: Suzanne Morphew,” an investigation into the mysterious vanishing of a Colorado mother. These episodes showcase the hosts’ meticulous research, attention to detail, and their ability to present complex cases in a digestible and compelling manner.

Crime Junkie has garnered an immense following, with listeners praising the hosts’ chemistry and their ability to deliver engaging content consistently. The podcast’s popularity is a testament to its quality and the dedication of its hosts in bringing true crime stories to life.

Casefile True Crime

While not directly affiliated with Crime Junkie, Casefile True Crime is another highly acclaimed podcast that deserves a place on any true crime enthusiast’s playlist. Hosted by an anonymous Australian narrator, Casefile delves into some of the most intriguing and lesser-known crime stories from around the world. The anonymity of the host adds a mysterious and suspenseful element to the podcast, allowing the focus to remain solely on the cases themselves.

Casefile True Crime episodes are meticulously researched and presented in a narrative style that keeps listeners engrossed from start to finish. The host’s attention to detail and ability to provide a comprehensive overview of each case make for an immersive listening experience. The podcast covers a wide range of crimes, from solved murders to unsolved mysteries and missing persons cases. Some standout episodes include “The East Area Rapist,” which chronicles the terrifying crimes of the notorious Golden State Killer, and “The Moors Murders,” a chilling exploration of a series of murders committed by Ian Brady and Myra Hindley.

With its dedication to factual accuracy and compelling storytelling, Casefile True Crime has gained a loyal following of listeners who appreciate the podcast’s in-depth approach to true crime.

My Favorite Murder

My Favorite Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. This podcast takes a unique approach to true crime, blending dark subject matter with humor and personal anecdotes. Karen and Georgia have a natural comedic chemistry that adds a refreshing and lighthearted touch to the often grim world of true crime.

Each episode of My Favorite Murder features the hosts discussing their favorite murder cases, as the title suggests. The podcast stands out for its conversational style, with Karen and Georgia sharing their thoughts, reactions, and personal connections to the cases they cover. They make you feel like you’re sitting with friends, discussing the macabre and sharing your mutual fascination with true crime.

What sets My Favorite Murder apart is its emphasis on inclusivity and community. The hosts encourage their listeners, known as “Murderinos,” to engage with the podcast through social media platforms, live shows, and fan meetups. This sense of community has created a devoted fan base that actively supports and connects with each other over their shared love for true crime.

Some notable episodes from My Favorite Murder include “The Golden State Killer,” which covers the infamous crimes committed by Joseph James DeAngelo, and “The Boy in the Box,” an exploration of the unsolved case of an unidentified child found in a cardboard box. These episodes showcase the hosts’ ability to balance humor and empathy, allowing listeners to explore the dark side of humanity while finding solace in the shared experience of true crime fascination.

My Favorite Murder has become a cultural phenomenon, not only for its entertainment value but also for its impact on destigmatizing conversations around mental health and trauma. Karen and Georgia’s openness about their own struggles resonates with many listeners, creating a safe space for discussions that go beyond true crime.

Whether you’re a fan of true crime or simply enjoy a good laugh, My Favorite Murder offers a unique perspective on the genre. It’s a podcast that reminds us that even in the darkest moments, finding humor and connection can be a powerful coping mechanism.


Criminal is a true crime podcast hosted by Phoebe Judge, which takes a unique approach to storytelling within the genre. Unlike other podcasts that focus solely on murder cases, Criminal explores a wide range of fascinating and lesser-known criminal stories. From art heists to identity theft, each episode of Criminal offers a fresh perspective on the world of crime.

What sets Criminal apart is its narrative style and the attention given to the human element of the stories. Phoebe Judge, with her calming voice and engaging storytelling abilities, transports listeners into the lives of both the criminals and the victims. The podcast delves into the motivations, circumstances, and consequences of various crimes, offering a deeper understanding of the complexities of human behavior.

Criminal episodes often feature interviews with individuals directly involved in the cases, including victims, witnesses, investigators, and sometimes even the perpetrators themselves. This adds an intimate and personal touch to the storytelling, allowing listeners to gain insights and empathy for the people involved.

Notable episodes from Criminal include “Episode 70: The Procedure,” which explores the world of underground plastic surgery, and “Episode 56: Just Mercy,” a powerful story about the fight for justice in the face of wrongful convictions. These episodes highlight the diversity of topics covered in Criminal, showcasing the podcast’s ability to shed light on lesser-known criminal acts and explore the intricacies of the justice system.

Criminal has received critical acclaim for its storytelling prowess and has been recognized with numerous awards, including the Radiotopia Showcase Award for Best New Podcast. The podcast’s success can be attributed to Phoebe Judge’s ability to craft compelling narratives that go beyond the sensationalism often associated with true crime. Criminal offers a thought-provoking and nuanced exploration of the human experience within the realm of crime.

With its unique approach and commitment to telling diverse and engaging stories, Criminal is a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts looking for a fresh perspective on the genre.

Sword and Scale

Sword and Scale is a true crime podcast hosted by Mike Boudet that delves into the darkest and most disturbing aspects of criminal behavior. This podcast takes a unique approach by exploring cases that push the boundaries of human depravity, offering a chilling glimpse into the depths of the human psyche.

What sets Sword and Scale apart is its intense and unflinching storytelling style. The podcast doesn’t shy away from the gruesome details of the crimes it covers, providing a raw and unfiltered account of the darkest corners of humanity. Each episode is meticulously researched and expertly narrated, immersing listeners in the chilling narratives.

Sword and Scale covers a wide range of cases, including serial killers, cults, and even cases involving the supernatural. The podcast aims to uncover the psychological motivations behind these crimes, diving deep into the minds of both the perpetrators and the victims. This exploration of the human psyche adds a thought-provoking element to the podcast, inviting listeners to ponder the complexities of criminal behavior.

Notable episodes from Sword and Scale include “Episode 20: The Antron Singleton Interview,” in which the host interviews a former gang member and convicted murderer, and “Episode 150: The Malicious Stalking of Sophie Sergie,” a haunting story of a young woman’s brutal murder. These episodes showcase the podcast’s ability to explore the darkest aspects of crime while maintaining a respectful and empathetic approach to the victims.

Sword and Scale has faced some controversy and criticism due to its graphic content and occasional lack of sensitivity. However, it continues to attract a dedicated following of true crime enthusiasts who appreciate its unfiltered and unapologetic exploration of the darkest side of human nature.

It’s important to note that Sword and Scale may not be suitable for all listeners, particularly those who are sensitive to graphic and disturbing content. However, for true crime enthusiasts seeking a no-holds-barred exploration of the darkest crimes, Sword and Scale offers a chilling and immersive listening experience.